Last Thursday provided us with yet another turning point in this Survivor season. Unfortunately, Satan willed himself to another victory in the Survivor franchise, taking claim of not only Adam and Parvati but several members of the Aitu tribe as well.
We open with everyone walking back from Tribal Council where Candice was recently voted off. Johnathan delves into a really lenghty “Everybody take a look at the bad guy” speech after being personally degraded for ten straight minutes on national television. I must say, he is handling all of this really well considering all of the unfair critiques about his character. We cut to credits after an unusually short pre-credits scene.
Everyone is working, Ozzy fishes and even Parvati is chopping coconuts, until she misses and damn near hacks off her thumb. Everyone gives their own impression of how queasy the cut made them feel. Except for Johnathan, who actually holds her other, fully intact hand, and encourages: “Your being so brave right now” as the doctor stiches her up. What a sadist.
At Reward Challenge we discover this is the seasonal family reunion episode. Everyone exchanges hugs and gets all misty eyed because it has been oh so long since they have seen each other. Johnathan’s wife, Parvati’s and Adam’s fathers, Becky’s sister, Yul’s brother and Sundra and Ozzy’s mother’s are all reigning in the emotional encounters. Needless too say I never understand the wave of uncontrollable emotion this has on Survivor contestants, guess you have to experience it because everyone, every season breaks down. Except for Becky, who’s ice cold heart hell could not melt.
Jeff informs us that our guest relatives will be participating in today’s challenge. Essentially, each contestant is blindfolded and handed a bucket to scoop water out of the ocean, turn around and throw it too there family member standing ten feet away with a their own small bucket too catch the water with and a larger one they must fill up in order to tip a scale and raise a flag. Its one of those typical Survivor challenges that they pull out for the family members. You know, on ethats predicated on communication and trust and all other intangibles that inhabit a healthy coexistence within a family. I get it.
Anyways, the challenge is fairly dull. Johnathan’s wife, Kelly, decides that wringing the water out of her shirt into the bucket is just as effective as the water she catches in from her Beau. Parvati’s Dad follows suit and utilizes the exact same tactic. It’s hard too tell, but according to Jeff’s narrating the challenge comes down to those two, with the result of Parvati and her father edging out Johnathan and his wife.
She immediately sends Johnathan to Exile Island. As expected, her father is allowed to join her on the reward, and Jeff informs us that two other contestants along with their family members are allowed to join them, but Parvati’s father has to invite which pairs are tagging along without deliberating with his daughter. Wisely, he bases his selection based on the other visiting family members that I am sure he spent some time with, as opposed to arbitrarily selecting Parvati’s competition based on some frivolous details. He selects Sundra and her mom along with (luckily for Parvati) Adam and his dad.
Back at camp, Ozzy is childishly annoyed that the only two members of the remaining Raro alliance have won the last two challenges (adam won the last immunity). He even takes credit for Parvati’s win because she eats all the food he collects and never brings any too camp herself. If anything, Johnathan’s wife is responsible for that win, since Parvati’s dad had the foresight to parrot her wringing the shirt into the bucket strategy, I think he is taking entirely too much credit without recognizing the part Mrs. Penner played in all this. So he proposes to Yul and Becky not feeding them for awhile. They all agree to hide the coconuts. I understand their logic, but damn does it seem vindictive.
The reward is worthwhile. The six fortunate souls meet up with yet another native tribe and visit this cave with beautiful blue fresh water. They all jump into it and get some food afterwards all the while they gush about how fufilling the whole experience is and gives the three of them time to concur they all hate Johnathan. Which, I don’t know. Are they so limited in topical conversation they always have to resort to this? he really doesn’t strike me as a bad guy, by any stretch of the imagination. I mean, if you look at fingergate, he was the only one providing any emotional support while Adam was fretting iover how it made him look. Kinda strange they have managed to use him as a scapegoat.
Sundra, Parvati and Adam; knowing that Johnathan won’t be at camp, all return with leftover reward challenge food in hand for Ozzy, Becky and Yul. Apparently they decided to share the coconuts after this. Way to take the moral high ground, fellas. Economically speaking, while they probably enjoy the chicken, biscuits and cornbread more than anyone enjoys fish and coconuts at this point, it is still only one meal versus dozens that Adam and Parvati have bilked off of Ozzy and Johnathan. So technically they do not owe them anything but I guess it is the easier, less combative route, which is probably the one I would take.
The Immunity Challenge is brutal. It entails swimming out to this balance course, swimming across another stretch of water, grabbing a bag full of sticks, then running back across said course and swimming too shore. After they go through the course and grab two bags, they then take the sticks out of the bag to form a long pole and grab three rings off a board from roughly fifteen feet away.
Since it is nautical based, Ozzy wins handily. In fact, the only person even working on their pole when Ozzy finishes is Yul. For the swimming based challenges, Ozzy should really be weighed down just to make things even remotely fair. I mean, he was returning his second bag before any female contestant returned their first.
The tribe is hanging around, shooting the breeze about how physically daunting the challenge was. Then Johnathan shows up, and the entire group falls dead silent. He then asks queries about the state of Becky’s sister, and Becky is non-responsive. The whole thing is very high-schoolish, but the camera work on this is a little shoddy, and it is unclear how much of it is selective editing. Because I want to sympathize with Johnathan in this predicament I have determined that none of it is. Adam goes into the woods and again tries to coerce Yul into voting out Johnathan, Yul interviews that he feels like The Godfather, proving that when you are considered a leader on Survivor, its almost inevitable that it will go to your head. he says he is uneasy about the prospect, so at least there is one redeemable player left in the game.
Johnathan then pleads his case to “The Godfather”, and reminds Yul that the Aitu alliance could have been crippled if he had not flipped on Raro two weeks ago. And while it is true, telling someone how indebted they are to you is never a solid Survivor strategy.
Johnathan voice overs that he thinks his alliance is still strong, and considering what he did for Aitu, if they decide to break their promise to him because Parvati smiles at them, or Adam gathers a little firewood or they bring them a little food from the RC, then there is nothing else he can do. He learns just how loose those promises are when he catches Sundra and Becky going out to gather firewood and there is so much distrust, and really a lot of animosity directed at Johnathan that it really alters the hugh opinion I had of Becky and Sundra. And it goes sort of like this:
Johnathan: Hey, what are you up to?
Becky: We’re just going to gather firewood.
Johnathan: Are we still voting for Adam?
Becky: That’s what we said.
And this doesn’t really do the scene justice. It is handily the most passive aggressive exchange I have ever witnessed on Survivor, and that is quite the accomplishment. During the encounter Sundra is mentally attempting to pull Becky away and won’t even make eye contact with Johnathan as the two of them do their best Mean Girls impression.
At Tribal Council, all of the attention is focused on whether or not Johnathan is a decent person. Even Ozzy concedes that it was pleasant with Johnathan being away from camp. And that might be true because you don’t have two self-entitled, spoiled little brats wallowing about not getting their way all the time, but that doesn’t mean Johnathan is at fault. Johnathan again states that he saved the Aitu tribe from being decimated in similar fashion to what is currently happening with Raro. Which may or may not be true, because Yul could have given anyone on his alliance the idol, so Nate still would have gone, and the following week would have been a 4-4 split and who knows what would happen the following week? But he continues to plead his case, Adam even has the audacity to suggest their are several people on the jury who deserve to still be playing in the game. Johnathan rightfully points out that outside of Nate and Candice, Adam voted off the other four members. And he has nothing to respond with, because Johnathan doesn’t have a foot to stand on, he is simply wrong. And somehow he has self appointed himself alongside Parvati as the moral arbiters of this season, which is ironic because the two of them are the most immoral people remaining, or at least thats what the selective editing would suggest.
Anyhow, the vote reveals that their bullying tactics actually worked and Johnathan is sent home. In his parting words he summarizes that it is just a game, people lie and deceive all the time in Survivor, and that four of the remaining six will still be on the jury. He also adds that he wished they would have just told him to his face instead of lying about it, because they were very transparent.
Next week: Ozzy considers flipping, Yul senses it and says he will delegate to Becky.
Links and The Wire summary of the season finale. I have needed a couple of days to gather my thoughts about this one.