Site Meter Grid Effect » Blog Archive » Adaptations & Compromises

Adaptations & Compromises

by State School Elitist

We’re plum out of material this morning. So when in doubt, always attempt to conjure up some wild speculation and make a bigger deal out of it than it really is. So that’s what we’ll do today, because as far as actual television to dissect and discuss we’re still suffering from what the networks have to provide. A friend of mine asked me what I’m going to do once The Wire finishes its series three weeks from now (rumor is the finale won’t be on demand).

And that is a good question, I’m either going to turn this into a sports blog or put a bullet in my head. Tough to say, probably whichever is most convenient at the time. In other words, which is in my nearest vicinity: a computer or a gun. I don’t own any guns, and anyone who we would watch the finale with doesn’t either, so this whole thing resolves itself. And see, who said violence on television is desensitizing? Given, my friends and I might be ill-prepared for any sort of revolution, but we live in Columbus, Ohio; so the cause for concern is slim to none. The only time a firearm is useful in Columbus is when OSU beats Michigan or a non-conference opponent early in the season, then you can prevent a clan of rowdy frat boys from going all Rosewood on your house.

Anyway, when we heard there is potential for a Wire movie, or at least it was mentioned in this interview with Dominic West, we decided things might not be so grim after all. What with the rampant speculation of an Arrested Development movie, we might have to bail on television sooner rather than later if film is the only outlet for material of this caliber. Given, David Simon said he went into the Wire with a five season plan, but he also went into it with the notion that Omar would die in the first season, and he started the fifth season with the impression he’d have a full twelve episodes.

Point being, plans often change, and I could see a Wire movie working perfectly fine. They’d just have to condense their usual length to a 150 minute max (actually your average Wire fan could probably sit through a five hour saga if given the same stylization), which would entail fewer plot lines, but if that gives us an illustration of McNulty and Bunk when they first started working in homicide together, then the last place you’ll here any complaints from is this website. People are quick to suggest that adapting successful films or television shows into one or the other always kills the efficacy of what was accomplished. Sports media and fans are apt to saying this as well about athletes who come out of retirement.

zigs.jpg
Yeah, like a shitty movie would tarnish this image.

We call bullocks. The notion that Michael Jordan’s legacy is tarnished because he teetered along for two sub-par seasons in his early forties with the Wizards in which they failed to make the playoffs is absurd. It wasn’t exactly glamorous, but has anyone forgotten about all the playoff games from the two 3-peats? If anything, his playing stint in Washington has been swept under the rug and abandoned by the collective memory of NBA die hards.

If The Wire writers were unable make the leap from television to film and produced a clunker (which we’d find totally flummoxing), the same thing would happen. Anyone who would watch this movie and felt like it betrayed the series, wouldn’t forget the Bodie’s or Wallace’s or Sobotka’s or Freamon’s, but rather in three months time they’d forget about the $10 they spent to see a movie they’d otherwise wish didn’t exist. And while we know Simon is indifferent towards awards or any sort of critical recognition, I think I speak for all fans when I say that if the Emmy’s won’t recognize him, it would sure as shit be great if the Oscar’s did.

Switching gears, NBC is discussing a potential movie of their own. It appears that they figure if they can’t attract a regular audience for Friday Night Lights to warrant renewing the series, then they might as well give it a two hour finale, in what they’re calling a made for TV movie. While this is better than nothing and more than any of us could hope for, we do not like this label. Considering the bulk majority of the series revolves around high school students, that means in the span of two hours someone will die of cancer, a drunk driving accident and/or a heroin addiction.

But still, two hours of Friday Night Lights to tie up the bevy of loose ends is almost necessary for its preservation. No one wants to stake claim in a series about football that ends in the middle of a season, and word of mouth will cease and desist, leaving its legacy almost non-existent. So we say on with the two hours (if not a series extension), we’ll take all the after-school specialness that can afford us if it at least attempts a bit of finality.

The good news is that Peter Berg directed the theatrical release of FNL, so he at least brings as much experience as possible to such an endeavor. Jesus, it just dawned on us, a theatrical film, a television series, and a potential television movie…we wonder if H.G. Bissinger had suspicion that his acclaimed novel would blow up like this while he was writing it.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Grid Effect. It's Free!

One Response to “Adaptations & Compromises”

  1. Alexis Ayers Says:

    0a4a6c3boeuleit5

Leave a Reply


About Grid Effect

Here at Grid Effect we discuss a morass of television series and recap a select few that are deemed worthy of such attention. We also provide a weekly links post that keeps you informed on all worthwhile topics in the television industry. In short, if you watch Desperate Housewives, American Idol, Grey's Anatomy or Two and A Half Men... this isn't the site for you (451 Press provides other such pages you can link to at the bottom). With a couple exceptions, we try to focus our efforts on the more cerebral qualities of your idiot box.

Grid Effect Author(s)
    » State-School-Elitist
    » State-School-Elitist

TV Channel Posts

  • Will Paula Abdul really leave 'Idol'?
    Will Paula Abdul be dancing off to exit stage left? That's this week's biggest Idol question. These days, Paula Abdul is making headlines at the rate of Britney Spears. The famed American Idol [...]
  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from The Young & the Restless. This is a clip of Nina confronting her husband David Kimble on all of the lies that he had been telling her. This week after seeing Tricia Cast [...]
  • The Office Season 5 Episode 8 Frame Toby
    Toby is back at his old HR desk, causing a lot of anxiety for Michael who wasn't aware of this and who still haven't come to terms with Holly, former HR and the love of his life, leaving [...]
  • TV Watch...
    Good morning, everyone!! How are y’all? I thought today I’d share some TV listing with you so you can see some of your favorites in other roles. Let’s start with something that fits the season [...]
  • Watching the View Off-Topic Thread: November 21, 2008
    This is where you can discuss things other than The View. This thread is not monitored. [...]
  • The Fray: You Found Me Complete Lost Promo Video
    I got chills. I got goosebumps. I wish January 21st could get any sooner. Here's the complete promo video from Lost featuring the song by The Fray which was aired during Grey's Anatomy earlier [...]
  • Thursday Night Recappin!
    -:07 - Seems that my East Coast stream is MIA today - if they pop up, I'll get to recapping, otherwise the full recap will have to wait for my own time zone. Sorry ya'll! :00 AHA! Host is delayed [...]
  • Rosie O'Donnell Responds to Today's Comments by Barbara Walters
    On her blog, Rosie O'Donnell posted this video response to the comments that Barbara Walters made about her on The View today. Thanks to Holly for mentioning the video in a comment. I [...]
  • Awesome Night
    [caption id="attachment_613" align="aligncenter" width="425" caption="Pushing Daisies "][/caption] It looks like I wasn't the only one who was curious who Jason Alexander would do as a serial [...]
  • Sarah Paulson, coming soon to a screen near you
    For a while there, during the election season, every Google Alert I got for "Sarah Paulson" turned out to be about Sarah Palin and Henry Paulson. But now the actress is getting at least a few [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Two Retailers Declare Bankruptcy
    Retailers are grabbing at every last ditch effort possible to save their businesses in a dying realm. Sales, free shipping online, collaborations with lower market stores, buyouts ... sometimes [...]
  • The Fray: You Found Me Complete Lost Promo Video
    I got chills. I got goosebumps. I wish January 21st could get any sooner. Here's the complete promo video from Lost featuring the song by The Fray which was aired during Grey's Anatomy earlier [...]
  • Week-long activities educate about transgender daily lives
    Transgender Awareness Week has brought education and attention about transgender issues. Shannon Jolliff, Office of Gay and Lesbian Programs director, said it has been a success on campus. "The [...]
  • Madonna unviels Gucci NFL turf collection in New York
    Who knew Madonna was such an NFL fan? How big a fan you ask? Well she wore a lovely Gucci Astroturf inspired gown to an event in New York the other night. Madge is so committed to the gridiron that [...]
  • Utley Out Until June 2009?
    This is not good for Phillie fans, not good at all... Three-time All-Star Chase Utley, who anchored the middle of the lineup for the World Series champion Phillies, will have surgery and may [...]
  • WWE Diva Maria: "Green Goddess" - Photos
    [gallery] Here is todays and the week-end diva, maria, your green goddess....enjoy!!!! [...]
  • Seattle Weekend Edition for 11/22/08
    We are just one week from Thanksgiving and just over a month away from Christmas. The Christmas sales are everywhere and stores are doing everything they can to lure your into their stores. Have you [...]
  • finally, I draw names from a hat
    I've decided it's about time to announce some winners. Who has won what? I'm not sure what I promised, or what people want (I am distressingly vague today) so if your name is on the list, email [...]
  • Friday Free-for-All - Romance
    Hello and welcome to the Friday Free-for-All! I don't know about you, but I am more than ready for this week to be over... Inspired by the Weekend Soiree over at Wifely Steps (and pretty much [...]
  • Onobun, Hill lead big men in frontcourt
    He's built like a linebacker, has the smile of a child and the patience of a saint. After three years of under-accomplishment and the contemplation of a transfer from Arizona, this is finally [...]