Site Meter Grid Effect » Blog Archive » Emmys Leave Something to be Desired

Emmys Leave Something to be Desired

by State School Elitist

Well, my head is spinning with the multitude of oversights this year, but I don’t know what else to expect from an award show that is clearly being compromised by someone or something. Either that or they are simply lazy. I hate to be so cynical but there is really no other explanation.

Note: This article will contain some spoilers, so if you’re waiting for some series’ to be released on DVD or whatever else, this post will upset you immensely if you continue to read.

For starters, lets give credit where credit is due: fifteen nominations for The Sopranos! Yowza! Obviously for best drama and both lead acting categories, then three supporting acting nominations (Imperioli, Bracco and Turturro) then three nominations in the best writing category for “Kennedy and Heidi” (The episode Chris died), “The Second Coming” (AJ’s suicide attempt) and the series finale, “Made In America”. All this in addition to a directing nomination for Alan Taylor for “Kennedy and Heidi” (I Get It!) and five other nominations in minor categories.

There were some other various highlights with the dramatic series nominations, including Dennis Leary getting a best actor nomination (which is a lost cause, I’m pretty sure based on the overwhelming recognition that The Sopranos very well might end up sweeping), Friday Night Lights, though clearly underappreciated did pick up a best directing and best casting (which is like an award for best ensemble), its minimal, but at least it is something.

The Wire, on the other hand, was completely snubbed. In this blogs humble opinion, this oversight completely diminishes all credibility The Emmys may have built up. This series is so nuanced, so well characterized and structured, its intriguing, insightful, entertaining and probably the only series that I can say with any cerititude that is actually important; and for it to get zero nominations is a fucking embarrassment. The only plausible explanation is either they aren’t watching it (most likely), its not popular so it goes unrecognized because there won’t be any mainstream outrage (quite possible), or race is actually an issue (never would have thought this to be the case as I am hesitant to play this card, but now I’m not so sure). It has to be one of these three, because if one watches the series in total, and isn’t subjective in any way, then there is no rationale for this series to not have a nomination in every major and minor category. It is that good.

Thing is, this really shouldn’t come as any shock. The Wire is virtually snubbed every year it should be in contention to clean house. I really shouldn’t take it so personally but the series deserves better. The Emmys are essentially the only mainstream outlet that acknowledges excellence in television, and for The Wire to go unrepresented is a sham. If The Emmys would give this show its due, then maybe it could build up the audience it deserves. But ultimately, those who watch The Emmys are not interested in a slew of no-names collecting awards, and that might be what this is attributed to. Most would rather see Kiefer Sutherland or one of the twenty-five year old smoking hot doctors from Grey’s Anatomy stockpile hardware. Not a gritty, realistic portrayal or institutional and urban decay and corruption. And that is no disrespect to 24 or the hospital drama, but give me a fucking break.

Like stated before, The Sopranos very well may sweep on Emmy night and that is all well and good. But it should really be rivaled by its artistic and narrative counterpart in The Wire, otherwise everything David Chase & Co. wins is borderline fraudulent. For a sports analogy, its would be like winning a Superbowl because the other team died in a plane crash. Technically, someone is awarded the Lombardi trophy, but did they really earn it? Or feel good about it?

Back later with some approving editorial on the comedy nominations (sans a few nitpicks), other miscellaneous categories and some more on Friday Night Lights, right now I need to karate chop some bricks so I don’t chuck my monitor across my office.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Grid Effect. It's Free!

One Response to “Emmys Leave Something to be Desired”

  1. Grid Effect » Blog Archive » It’s Always Sunny May Never End Says:

    [...] If you care about this sort of thing, this guy is predicting that Mad Men will clean up at the Emmy’s. We didn’t read much of the article, but we assume the theory is related to the fact that many of the Emmy voters grew up around the same time the series is set (early 60’s), are extremely liberal and like seeing their mystique of this time period stripped away. Either way, I hope he is right. Although, I wouldn’t be too disappointed if this were another Wire situation with the Emmy’s completely ignoring what is now the best series on television. Again. [...]

Leave a Reply


About Grid Effect

Here at Grid Effect we discuss a morass of television series and recap a select few that are deemed worthy of such attention. We also provide a weekly links post that keeps you informed on all worthwhile topics in the television industry. In short, if you watch Desperate Housewives, American Idol, Grey's Anatomy or Two and A Half Men... this isn't the site for you (451 Press provides other such pages you can link to at the bottom). With a couple exceptions, we try to focus our efforts on the more cerebral qualities of your idiot box.

Grid Effect Author(s)
    » State-School-Elitist
    » State-School-Elitist

TV Channel Posts

  • Alimony Matters on Gary Unmarried
    In this week's installment of Gary Unmarried, we find Gary suddenly realizing that the sooner Allison and Dr. Krandall get married, the sooner he can stop paying alimony. So he set about telling Dr. [...]
  • Band From TV at the Mohegan Sun, October 11
    The Band from TV rocked the grand opening celebration of the Casino of the Wind at Mohegan Sun last night in Uncasville, Connecticut.  On hand were band members James Denton, Greg Grunberg, Bob [...]
  • Paris Bennett is a mommy ... and other 'Idol' tidbits
    Right about now, you can bet Paris Bennett is adjusting to motherhood. The 19-year-old former American Idol finalist gave birth to her first child, a girl named Egypt, on Monday. The [...]
  • More Rock of Love
    There is more Rock of Love coming to VH1, only this time there is no Brett Michaels looking for love. This time fourteen of the most obnoxious, ridiculous contestants from Rock of Love are going to [...]
  • Tonight, Justin and Rebecca are employed, and maybe nobody else
    New episode tonight! Here's what ABC's press release says we have to look forward to: "Tug of War - Holly takes her authority at Ojai Foods too far and pushes Saul and Sarah to their limits. [...]
  • New Episodes of Kids Shows This Week
    Welcome to this week’s edition’s list of kid’s television shows that have new episodes airing this week. I try to make this as complete as possible, but I may sometimes miss something. Please [...]
  • Mostly Ghostly on Disney Channel Review
    I did not watch this live last night because I was out of the house, but I watched it on my DVR this morning. I was actually quite impressed by Mostly Ghostly: Who Let the Ghosts Out? [...]
  • BBi update!
    With the just posted eviction, we close up on week two, and I'm still there! WHOOHOOO! Not so easy to get rid of me, it seems! We had our first 'food' competition this week, and the version [...]
  • Five questions: "Book Burning"
    Five questions about last Sunday's episode -- "Book Burning" -- still rattling around in my brain: 1. Why didn't Nora cook at Kitty's house? I grew up about halfway between Pasadena and Santa [...]
  • Mad Men: "The Inheritance"
    We mentioned on Friday that Mad Men last Sunday, along with the Entourage episode on the same night seemed a little off-beat to what we are accustom too from both series. The difference being the [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Mostly Ghostly on Disney Channel Review
    I did not watch this live last night because I was out of the house, but I watched it on my DVR this morning. I was actually quite impressed by Mostly Ghostly: Who Let the Ghosts Out? [...]
  • Let's get 30 Rocked!
    With the start of 30 Rock's third season fast approaching, NBC has released a preview of upcoming guest appearances, including Jen's! As previously mentioned, on the November 13th episode, Jen [...]
  • Band From TV at the Mohegan Sun, October 11
    The Band from TV rocked the grand opening celebration of the Casino of the Wind at Mohegan Sun last night in Uncasville, Connecticut.  On hand were band members James Denton, Greg Grunberg, Bob [...]
  • New Episodes of Kids Shows This Week
    Welcome to this week’s edition’s list of kid’s television shows that have new episodes airing this week. I try to make this as complete as possible, but I may sometimes miss something. Please [...]
  • Pope Announces India's First Woman Saint
    India's Christians have something to celebrate today: At St. Peter's Square Pope Benedict XVI declared four new saints to the Roman Catholic church including an Indian woman. Her canonization is a [...]
  • Frierson's Two Late Goals Lead Auburn To 2-1 Victory Over Arkansas
    In the span of three minutes, Katy Frierson turned what looked to be a loss into a key victory for Auburn as she scored twice in the final 11 minutes to lead Auburn to a 2-1 win on Sunday at [...]
  • Doggie boot camp!!!
    Would you send your dog to Doggie Boot Camp? If the instructor had 40 years in dog training experience and is currently the only canine instructor that is certified by both New York City and New [...]
  • More Cena Photos at Kids Award and Working Out Mag. Shoot
    [gallery] John Cena in Australia for the Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards in Melbourne, October 2008 More photos of John Cena at Australian Kids' Choice Awards. Photos of John Cena working out [...]
  • What are your kids eating today?
    We've all heard stories of a friend who was in Wal-Mart and witnessed a seven-year old using a pacifier and a one-year old with a bottle full of Coke. Some of us prefer to feed our kids as much [...]
  • Amazing Angelina Jolie Interview!
    Wow. There is an absolutely amazing interview that Angelina did with the Philippine Daily Inquirer. She talks about everything from working to her children - here are a few snippits: What are [...]